Small Butt Plugs

25 products

Sort by:

Adam & Eve Red Hearts Gem Anal Plug

(148) 4.800000190734863 stars out of 5

$3.99 - $7.99 $14.99 - $24.99 Save Up to $21.00 (84%)

Adam & Eve Pink Gem Anal Plug Set

(131) 4.75 stars out of 5

$54.99

Adam and Eve Booty Bumper Anal Dildos & Plug Set

(5) 4.800000190734863 stars out of 5

$19.99 $59.99 Save $40.00 (67%)

Adam & Eve Glitter Gem Butt Plug Set

(46) 4.849999904632568 stars out of 5

$23.99 $39.99 Save $16.00 (40%)

Teal
Pink

Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Plug Set

(36) 4.75 stars out of 5

$54.99

Adam & Eve Rose Gold Pink Heart Anal Training Set

(12) 4.849999904632568 stars out of 5

$44.99

Nixie Metal Butt Plug and Fur Cuff Set

(13) 3.8499999046325684 stars out of 5

$29.99

Purple
Electric Blue
Hot Pink

Inya Alpine Vibrating and Rotating Anal Plug

(17) 4.199999809265137 stars out of 5

$59.99

Rocks Off Petite Sensations Plug

(31) 3.6500000953674316 stars out of 5

$27.99

Dark Droplets 3 Piece Silicone Anal Trainer

(19) 4.300000190734863 stars out of 5

$14.99

Try-Curious Anal Plug Kit

(18) 4.599999904632568 stars out of 5

$34.99

Pink
Purple

Adam & Eve Three Hearts Gem Anal Plug Set

(76) 4.650000095367432 stars out of 5

$54.99

Naughty Silicone Butt Plug

(305) 4.5 stars out of 5

$15.99 - $19.95

Booty Sparks Pink Rose Glass Anal Plug

(26) 4.849999904632568 stars out of 5

$19.99 - $27.95

Booty Sparks Pink Gem Glass Anal Plug

(24) 4.650000095367432 stars out of 5

$15.99 - $18.99

Fifty Shades of Grey Something Forbidden Butt Plug

(81) 4.400000095367432 stars out of 5

$19.99

Wild Secrets Dare Silcone Anal Trainer Kit product image 3

Wild Secrets Dare Silicone Anal Training Kit

(5) 3.4000000953674316 stars out of 5

$23.99 $59.99 Save $36.00 (60%)

Tailz Grey Wolf Anal Plug & Ears Set

(93) 4.400000095367432 stars out of 5

$59.99

Adam & Eve Rainbow Heart Anal Training Set

(10) 5 stars out of 5

$44.99

Ass-Sation Vibrating Metal Anal Plug with Remote Control

(11) 3.75 stars out of 5

$79.99

Vibra-Ball Trio Weighted Anal Training Set standing on table

Adam & Eve Vibra-Ball Weighted Anal Training Set

(1) 4 stars out of 5

$54.99

Creature Cocks Eye Of The Dragon

$39.99

Green
Red

Butt Blaster Anal Tail #1

(7) 3.549999952316284 stars out of 5

$4.97 $22.95 Save $17.98 (78%)

Satisfyer Booty Absolute Beginner Anal Vibrator

(2) 3.5 stars out of 5

$48.99

You've seen 24 of 25 products

A small butt plug provides the perfect introduction to anal play for backdoor beginners.

When it Comes to Butt Plugs, It’s Smart to Start Small

Thinking of exploring anal play? A small butt plug is a good place to begin. Backdoor sex toys

stretch the anus so you need to work your way up to larger plugs. Don’t get greedy—safety is the top priority and you can derive plenty of pleasure from being penetrated by a modest anal toy.

How to Find the Best Beginner’s Butt Plug

Many couples have incorporated anal play into their sex lives, but a little education can go a long way as you get started. Consider the following when looking for the perfect small butt plug:

Materials. Your new butt plug should be made of a smooth, non-porous material that’s easy to clean. Silicone and glass are popular options. When it comes to butt play, hygiene is extremely important.
Anal training kits. You don’t have to settle on one butt plug. Anal trainers include several plugs and allow you to move up in size as you adapt to anal penetration.
Anal rimmers. These are the smallest butt plugs and are meant for external stimulation and light penetration. Consider an anal rimmer if you’re not sure if butt play is for you.
Extra anal features. Some butt plugs vibrate for additional stimulation while others feature bejeweled ends or tails that peek out from your behind. Inflatable butt plugs can gradually increase in size, allowing you or a partner to tease your backdoor. A butt plug with graduated spheres on the shaft turns up the intensity as it moves deeper.
Safety. Even small butt plugs require lots of lube to keep things safe and enjoyable. Anal lube is specially formulated to be extra-slippery, and you should order a supply when buying your new butt plug. Also—no matter the size—your butt plug needs to have a flared base to prevent complete insertion.